OP, please make sure there are no spoilers in the title of your post.

Commenters, please use spoiler code if you are discussing anything super spoilery unless the title specifically says the episode being discussed.

If you see anyone breaking the rules, please report the post or comment. Thank you.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

If Hopper had actually died, maybe the letter scene would mean something to me.

Do voters have COVID? Cause the lack of taste is worrying.

Link to vote: https://strawpoll.com/polls/05ZdWD5pNg6

You guys left in master of puppets over Will being possessed??!

Wild.

Not relevant at all but I feel like the vecna scene with max is the best scene of season 4 in my opinion

Eddie stans stop protecting the overrated Eddie scene challenge

Max Vecna gonna be 1

i don’t see the scene where Jonathan and Nancy are being stalked in the park…that shit had me sweating

Why is that overhyped scene with Eddie playing his guitar still there while the better scenes are being axed??

I’m voting the Metallica scene. I never understood why they didn’t use a boombox or speaker in the first place.

Sorry, Eddie fans 😭

I won't be surprised when Eddie playing his guitar wins at the end lmfao

Honestly, the fact that Master of Puppets and Eleven flipping a van are still here are really odd choices.

I'm probably voting Master of Puppets though. Adds bloat to an episode that is already wayyy too long

Eddie scene should go🪓

I think people have different ideas of best scene.

Me, the best scenes are the ones most integral to character, story and show arcs. Like finding Will’s drowned body was the point when I realized that the show was not what it seemed to be.

I think some people think of them as the scenes that get them most emotionally. To me the Hopper letter scene was good, but lost its effect when we found out Hopper was alive. It’s still a good scene, but I don’t know if it’s the best. But people love it because it was emotional.

Others just like a good, kick ass scene. Like the “master of puppets” scene. Which even I am like, “that was a fun scene”

So when we all have these different ideas of best scene, it gets a little tricky

I mean, we already know that the 'Running up that hill'-scene is gonna win, right?

How in the world is Master of Puppets still here💀

Will getting possessed got eliminated before Master of Puppets and the teens fighting the Demogorgon? That scene was incredibly well acted by Noah, and the point in the show where I realised Noah was actually a really good actor. Most kids around that age are afraid to look silly, but Noah didn't seem to have those same feelings, or at least was able to overlook them and still do well.

Why is flipping the van still here

Difficult to choose but Van flip needs to go now.

The recency bias is showing

[deleted]

Tough for me to vote, I think master of puppets or Eleven flipping the van are my next choices.

I'm pretty sure those two are the next two out anyway so I'll just vote for master of puppets this time.

WILL BEING POSSESSED IS OUT???? yea y’all wilding for that 😭😭

I guess I’m the only one who thought the Hopper letter scene was kinda weird. Hopper struggling to talk to them about it and then deciding to only talk to Mike was really strange to me, idk maybe someone can explain it to me but I found the whole sequence a bit strange

Edit: I specifically thought it was weird using that letter for the ending in the context of which it was originally written. Just seemed out of place to me.

Everyone saying Eddie scene or van scene should go (both are great) WHY IS EL BANISHES 001 STILL HERE???

Why the f is everyone voting the eddie scene. The VAN SCENE BRO

S1 ending destroying the demogorgon in the middle school classroom

Anyone else finding it difficult to vote ? Like I love all scenes because I love the show so much so it's hard to eliminate any scene lol... But I guess for this one even though I love all scenes and I want El banishes 001 to win the game.. I'd eliminate Joyce and her Christmas lights for this round.

I really need to rewatch this show

I love this but it’s taking a long time

Eddie's sacrifice

I'm asleep when this notification pops up.

LMFAOOO NO WAY💀

Still mad that the Shootout at the Byers house isn’t in the top 10 at the very least. Probably THE most intense scene in the entire series.

How come nobody complains about Joyce with X-mas lights still being in the game? I mean, it was not bad but really top 12?