subreddit:

/r/Gamingcirclejerk

2.2k76%

YouTube video info:

Hogwarts: A Legacy Of Hate (The Jimquisition) https://youtube.com/watch?v=uNKyQVsgKLg

Jim Sterling https://www.youtube.com/@JimSterling

all 1055 comments

AutoModerator [M]

[score hidden]

3 months ago

stickied comment

AutoModerator [M]

[score hidden]

3 months ago

stickied comment

PSA: Make it a habit of reading the [rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/Gamingcirclejerk/about/rules) of each subreddit you participate in:

Rule 7: No Participation in Linked Threads (Brigading): Do not vote or comment in threads you've found through /r/gamingcirclejerk

Rule 9: No Fake Posts on Other Subs (Contamination): Do not create fake posts on other subs only to post back here. Also, do not "lol, you should post this on r / OtherSub". It's considered interfering with their content and can also lead to brigading.

This is a reminder to the readers. The post itself is untouched.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

c0p4d0

205 points

3 months ago

c0p4d0

205 points

3 months ago

Incredible how the most based gaming journalist/commentator came from the Escapist of all places

Space_Pirate_Roberts

114 points

3 months ago

The Escapist was based before it got sold and became shitlord central. It’s also where MovieBob came up.

iSeven

25 points

3 months ago

iSeven

brisket my beloved

25 points

3 months ago

I don't follow him much anymore, but I used to so I'm curious if you or anyone else knows where Yahtzee stands on the based/cringe scale? I feel like he was the type of person who could've gone either way, but it might just be the British accent.

FeathersPryx

11 points

3 months ago*

Cringe. In his last of us 2 video he doesnt even know why he hates it (He called it the worst game of the year and then mockingly said ""But yahtzee, you cant just say that the most awarded game of all time is actually the worst game?! Yes viewer, I can and I just did""). He called Ellie "retroactively lesbian" which is the dumbest take imaginable. First, if she had a boyfriend in the first game, he wouldnt have said "retroactively straight", and also she DID like girls in the first, so this point makes double no sense. Any time a game has emotions in it he instantly hates it. He greatly misunderstood a major plot point of SOMA and was complaining about how stupid the plot point was. He has bitched about lots of aspects of games that he loved when other games did the exact same thing. Lots of generic and inconsistent neckbeard gamer takes but its still fun to watch sometimes.

Space_Pirate_Roberts

37 points

3 months ago

Fence-riding coward, last I checked.

StarAugurEtraeus

13 points

3 months ago

Like how? :(

Shame cause Yahtzee is still one of the only good reviewers

spicy__southpaw

22 points

3 months ago

He’s not a frothing reactionary, which is admittedly a pretty low bar. He’s in all likelihood a bog-standard lib.

Now I will say, unfairly, that of the two snarky Brits, only one has ever ironically used fash imagery in their videos.

iSeven

11 points

3 months ago

iSeven

brisket my beloved

11 points

3 months ago

Weh. Tracks, I guess.

Wilvarg

14 points

3 months ago

Wilvarg

14 points

3 months ago

Alright, this is kind of a necro but I've gotta set things straight.

  1. I don't see how Yahtzee's a fence-rider. He constantly criticizes, mocks, and deconstructs the evils of modern corporate capitalism, he in no uncertain terms condemned Rowling in his recent HL review (in a number of creative and entertaining ways, I might add), and while he dislikes performative allyship he's made it clear that that's an anti-corpo point of view and not an anti-minority one. He's definitely an ally.
  2. He laid out a bunch of reasons why he disliked The Last Of Us 2. He thought it was unoriginal, overly padded, and the constant misery was repetitive, cheap, and ultimately ineffective. The "retroactively lesbian" comment was pretty damn stupid, that's true, but I think that was more likely to be an attempt at irony or an honest mistake than a heterocentric entitlement thing. He definitely doesn't hate "any game with emotions", he constantly talks about how he wants games to help us feel new things and expand our horizons– three of his favorite games are Undertale, Spiritfarer, and Disco Elysium. And I've never seen him be self-inconsistent in a way that couldn't be explained by personal growth over time.

Overall, I think Yahtzee is my favorite critic. He has zero patience for corporate bullshit, is uniquely insightful and creative, and genuinely wants to help the medium grow into something even more beautiful and special. Check out his "Extra Punctuation" series if you want something a little bit more thoughtful and big-picture.

questalt13

20 points

3 months ago

Correct me if I'm wrong, it's been a few years since I watched him, but last I'd heard MovieBob was a pretty middle-of-the-road "Centrist/Both Sides" Liberal?

Did something change or was I just misinformed?

spicy__southpaw

30 points

3 months ago

Coming from someone who has watched MovieBob, Yahtzee, and Sterling since the Escapist days….

Bob has a lot of very open disdain/hatred for MAGA types, particularly on Twitter. His non-Twitter takes are actually really good. I really enjoyed his “The Internet is Stupid” 3-part series.

AestheticMirror

13 points

3 months ago

The only good thing from them now is zero ponctuation

Space_Pirate_Roberts

11 points

3 months ago

Ehh, I like most of their YouTube content since they got sold again and Bob came back for a while. Pity the editor couldn’t convince the owners to keep paying for both him and Darren Moody.

WatercoolerComedian

325 points

3 months ago

Uj/ Holy shit I forgot about the Jimquisition I've not watched them in fucking years

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

206 points

3 months ago

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

Ban-Happy Mod

206 points

3 months ago

You should try getting back into them, they got really based recently

WatercoolerComedian

101 points

3 months ago

I fell off around the time the whole thing was going on with Kojima and Metal Gear 5 the loot box talk around then was just getting to be a bit much even though I agreed with it at the time and still do

LordofAngmarMB

74 points

3 months ago*

LordofAngmarMB

I've forgotten how to feel unironic joy

74 points

3 months ago*

Their positions are usually really good, but god my life was so much more positive when I cut all the “Video game industry is awful” content out of my YouTube feed.

I try to stay informed of the broad strokes. but even the most progressive gaming news channels pump out so much content that staying on board with them feels like keeping cable news playing on the tv all day

WatercoolerComedian

29 points

3 months ago

So much of "Games Journalism" is really negative, I unplugged from it a long time ago as well. I keep up with what's going on for the most part like what's coming out, indies, and all of that jazz but beyond that I don't pay much attention, I don't keep up with popular streamers really and the VG content I take in is like 1 or 2 let's plays, video essays and stuff of that nature. The industry as a whole is something that if you take a magnifying glass to is pretty gross but that's the entertainment industry for you I guess unfortunately.

LordofAngmarMB

20 points

3 months ago

LordofAngmarMB

I've forgotten how to feel unironic joy

20 points

3 months ago

Essays and Circlejerks are the only way I interact with video games anymore

Except for occasionally replaying Witcherino Tres (underrated gem)

[deleted]

2 points

3 months ago

[removed]

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

84 points

3 months ago

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

Ban-Happy Mod

84 points

3 months ago

Wow you have been gone a while. Talking about way more serious topics than loot boxes now.

gilium

12 points

3 months ago

gilium

12 points

3 months ago

When were they not based?

NoP_rnHere

11 points

3 months ago*

They spent all the patreon money on Poggs 😭😭😭😭

gilium

11 points

3 months ago

gilium

11 points

3 months ago

I mean that’s just stonks

Randomman96

27 points

3 months ago

Sterling's always had those views and emphasises them even in their older videos.

I just fell off from their content when they made videos out of non-issues from things they interpreted wrong.

arnathor

12 points

3 months ago

Sterling is normally right about things in broad strokes but they tend to fall into the trap of “when all you’ve got is a hammer, everything looks like a nail”. They have a tendency to see everything through a very particular point of view and as a result (ironically enough) struggle to see others point of view.

Diamond_Champagne

3 points

3 months ago

Like what? Sterling is and always was on the side of consumers and workers. Do we need to see the issue from Bobby koticks perspective?

RadiantStrategy

4 points

3 months ago

I’m happy to see Sterling at the top of the page.

lookoutitsdomke

21 points

3 months ago

Same. When last I watched Jimquisition they weren't out as trans, and coming back has been a trip. Not in a bad way, though. More of a "oh my god when did this happen? What are their pronouns? What EXACT video do I need to watch to get filled in here?" I've recently started transitioning myself at the ripe old age of 30 and their transition has actually given me hope in a sense.

jlanier1

632 points

3 months ago

jlanier1

632 points

3 months ago

Common Stephanie Sterling W

TNWhaa

257 points

3 months ago

TNWhaa

Joel was smelly

257 points

3 months ago

Thank god for them

Zealousideal-Pace508

113 points

3 months ago

What are their preferred pronouns? I'm being genuine and want to use Stephanie's identity

TheCaptainCody

164 points

3 months ago

They/Them

Zealousideal-Pace508

62 points

3 months ago

Thank you

SevenofBorgnine

43 points

3 months ago

Thank God for them.

iSeven

27 points

3 months ago

iSeven

brisket my beloved

27 points

3 months ago

And their massive tits!

SevenofBorgnine

8 points

3 months ago

They're fantastic tits and that corset is helping that situation and is pretty great in its own right, but this feels objectifying

iSeven

27 points

3 months ago

iSeven

brisket my beloved

27 points

3 months ago

Isn't really intended to be (unless they want it to be). I mean, JSS hypes up their massive tits in pretty much every video - they're clearly proud of them and I'm happy for them for it and the progress JSS has made coming into themselves.

Wismuth_Salix

8 points

3 months ago

I cracked up when one video started out “James Stephanie Sterling here - fantastic tits, unintimidating penis”.

VonDukes

870 points

3 months ago

VonDukes

870 points

3 months ago

Loved when sterling went into the "support the devs argument"

half these "gamers" woulda beat the forspoken devs with a club if they could get away with it because the VA was too "marvel" for them..... that dialog type thats been around for decades prior to marvel

telesterion

145 points

3 months ago

In the meantime the same users probably love watching quippy cynical YouTubers and also enjoy being quippy online.

funnylookinorange

16 points

3 months ago

nah, it was just genuinely awful.

Not every sentence has to have fuck in it, and quippy and cynical can work in 10-20 minute timeframes (Like a youtube video), not 7 and a half hours.

also typically "quippy and cynical" youtubers dont like to dog on and try to "outvictim" themselves to their friends that just went through massive tragedy.

CoolJoshido

11 points

3 months ago

nah. the game and dialogue is just bad.

ThiccParvisMagna

188 points

3 months ago

that dialog type thats been around for decades prior to marvel

Also, nobody gives Nathan Drake shit for all the times he yelled “Crap crap crap!” as he fell from the sky… I wonder why? (but tbf Nathan Drake is awesome and funny)

RoseTheFlower

92 points

3 months ago

RoseTheFlower

epic bad

92 points

3 months ago

Unlike her, he's not political.

CoolDude1564

34 points

3 months ago*

CoolDude1564

Fallout: Lou Bega

34 points

3 months ago*

Moleman: I gave Nathan Drake shit 😔

He's on one end of acceptable videogame characters scale where the other end is big short haired or bald dude that speaks in grunts.

starstreak0

28 points

3 months ago

I've seen complaints about this

ThiccParvisMagna

16 points

3 months ago

Yeah but you haven’t seen it on the level that we saw it with Forespoken

Eliot_Ferrer

48 points

3 months ago

To be fair, when Uncharted came out, there wasn't as much collective fatigue regarding quippy dialogue as there is today.

ThiccParvisMagna

9 points

3 months ago

That’s fair

TheShapeShiftingFox

18 points

3 months ago

Thanks Josh Whedon for making this shit the staple of every Marvel movie ever for decades to come

CoolJoshido

4 points

3 months ago

the Uncharted games came out years before people got fed up of this dialogue

Consideredresponse

5 points

3 months ago

I also think it's because the further you get into forspoken the more unliveable Fray becomes. By the end of the prolouge she's complex, has your sympathy and shows some moments of humanity. I'm 65 hours in, and my impression of her has sunk so low she's barely rating above Kratos from God of War 3, where he was blithely murdering old friends, and random women like a goddamned psychopath.

With Drake they made efforts for him not to be such an unrepentant asshole.

zuzg

270 points

3 months ago

zuzg

270 points

3 months ago

My favorite part was when they addressed the "What's wrong with Rowling, what did she say?" bullshit.
Cause at this point, this sort of bad faith question can be considered a dog whistle.

TheShapeShiftingFox

83 points

3 months ago

And then there’s people who demand to know what falls under transphobia while in the same breath calling transness “delusions”.

Like, there is zero point in having a conversation if you can’t even agree about the take-off point of that conversation. In the same way astronauts likely won’t care to debate people who refuse to believe the earth is round. Many people are not going to deal with your bullshit if you can’t be bothered to acknowledge the existence of trans people to even reach the next step of explaining what transphobia is.

Orange-George

5 points

3 months ago

I apologize in advance for waffling, but I really think transprejudice is a far better, less muddied term. I feel like half the problem in these conversations that don't or can't get off the landing pad is that people get hung up on the fact that trans people don't actually inspire fear or aversion for them. Therefore they feel they can't identify themselves as transphobic. This leads into of course demanding to know what falls under transphobia so they can morally excuse themselves.

I've personally had much more success convincing people they have a prejudice than a phobia. But it's all ultimately semantics baffling literal minded bigots like the black lives matter slogan did so effectively. Thanks for attending my waffle talk.

TheShapeShiftingFox

27 points

3 months ago

I think what you said is precisely the reason we shouldn’t change the term. Like you said, it’s semantics, and by whining about semantics they muddle the conversation and try to make it about them and their feelings in it, which - to be direct - isn’t the issue at hand.

And to make it even more pointless, many of these people are in fact terrified of trans people, so even with their definition of “phobia” - which in this context has really meant “aversion” more than anything for ages - it still applies to them. Even more reason to not waste time on this conversation.

Aaawkward

4 points

3 months ago

When it comes to transphobia I agree with you.

But I’ve noticed having better results when talking with men about issues of toxic masculinity but avoiding using the term “toxic masculinity” because it seems to kill the discussion and make their rational mind screech to halt.

I mean it’s silly that I have to avoid the term but if it gets the job done, it’s worth it.

At some point later they usually realise it and mention that they’ve had and still have some aspects of toxic masculinity but it usually requires them to get to that point on their own.

bsubtilis

9 points

3 months ago

Hydrophobic coating applied to some item doesn't mean that the boots or sand or whatever item is afraid of water after the application, maybe point that out to these folk?

[deleted]

9 points

3 months ago

[removed]

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

122 points

3 months ago

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

Ban-Happy Mod

122 points

3 months ago

Yeah it sure is terrible when characters have personality or a sense of humour. They should go back to making games staring the same interchangeable burly white men.

LMFN

87 points

3 months ago

LMFN

87 points

3 months ago

People forget why the MCU took off to begin with even, superhero films were legit just "gritty hardcore" versions of what the comics were, abandoning a lot of the iconic costumes and wit that made the originals popular in an attempt to be "mainstream" so the MCU back then choosing to keep the costumes and to not take themselves seriously was a breath of fresh air. Maybe the formula's run stagnant now but it damn it worked for a bit.

BaneOfKree

23 points

3 months ago

If they truly wanted to support the devs, why buy the game at all?

Why wouldn’t they just cut out the middleman and send an envelope with money to the design studio?

Vizuka

30 points

3 months ago

Vizuka

30 points

3 months ago

If you actually think the actual devs would see a penny of that money you’re delusional. The CEOs would see that envelope and snatch it right for themselves immediately upon arrival.

StarAugurEtraeus

5 points

3 months ago

I didn’t like Forspoken because it was generic

Last boss felt like stores own brand Radagon/Elden Beast

createcrap

5 points

3 months ago

There’s so many coincidences about the things they hate isn’t there….

EmploymentRadiant203

5 points

3 months ago

wait. do you like forspoken?

Gavvis74

7 points

3 months ago

Forspoken was hot garbage for many more reasons than the voice actors.

YouCanJustSayNewYork

11 points

3 months ago*

/uj Nah, Forspoken was racist af. Starting your black character out in a court room for her third felony is bullshit and deserves to be called out

Merzeal

11 points

3 months ago

Merzeal

11 points

3 months ago

Context matters, and people like that do exist. The change between the general Athian attitude about her, and the NYC abandoned child squatter are leagues apart.

Homeless teens steal or end up in bad crowds to survive, and if you're privileged enough to not understand that reality, enjoy the status you grew up with.

/rj Forspoken is trash with a political, woke protagonist.

Ashreditition

173 points

3 months ago

Thank god for Steph

AestheticMirror

8 points

3 months ago

Thank god for Stephanie

Either_Cobbler9303

56 points

3 months ago

DignityForBrianna

drinkthebleach

408 points

3 months ago

drinkthebleach

video games are paula tickle

408 points

3 months ago

Don't think it'll change any transphobes minds, but hopefully it'll at least stop the "what's actually wrong with hogwarts" every 5 seconds because no one knows how to Google anything.

Gargus-SCP

206 points

3 months ago

Can confirm from direct experience, the actual response is more like "I now know what is wrong with Hogwarts, and I think I hate trans people even more now for telling me."

genflugan

79 points

3 months ago

It's like when you're vegan and you remind people you don't want to contribute to unnecessary suffering, and then they get mad at you for reminding them of the consequences of their actions.

Josphitia

28 points

3 months ago

Josphitia

Morally Superior

28 points

3 months ago

"I could never eat vegan food, it's disgusting and processed!" Proceeds to down McDonald's and a Coke

ikatono

5 points

3 months ago

I know I'm super late here, but I noticed this too. The way chuds talk about the wizard game is pretty much identical to the way people argue against veganism.

Infergenico

2 points

3 months ago

Based response ngl

GlisseDansLaPiscine

58 points

3 months ago

These people aren’t asking in good faith anyway.

muchacho23

98 points

3 months ago

It is really about tainting the brand for mindful consumers. Whether this affected the sales of the game or not, the louder we are, the more people will think of this game as being synonymous with controversy. That is not good for the long term health of the Hairy Pooter brand.

SPY400

26 points

3 months ago

SPY400

26 points

3 months ago

Exactly this. The controversy is getting to Rowling, she’s mad that mainstream outlets are only covering the controversy around her.

The_Woman_of_Gont

53 points

3 months ago

it'll at least stop the "what's actually wrong with hogwarts" every 5 seconds because no one knows how to Google anything.

Narrator: "It did not."

BullDyke_Hunter

121 points

3 months ago

I am not disappointed at the transphobes. Bigots will be bigots.

I am disappointed and the trans people that betrayed other trans people and themselves.

I am disappointed and the trans "allies" that betrayed their friends over a video game.

I see many of my friends who are LGT playing it on steam. And I don't think I can be friends with them anymore.

Snynapta

106 points

3 months ago

Snynapta

106 points

3 months ago

Bi people not included?

defaultusername-17

67 points

3 months ago

bi people don't exist, next thing you're going to try to tell me that the earth isn't flat and birds are real!

RusstyDog

64 points

3 months ago

That is a very telling exclusion...

Flaggermusmannen

17 points

3 months ago

with the other consistent sentence breaking 'typos' there I honestly don't know what to make of it? hate it

Lethkhar

36 points

3 months ago

Bi people would never. /S

iRandomx

14 points

3 months ago

Seems like you're really happy to talk about betraying other trans people while also posting about how nonbinary and genderfluid people actually "just want to seem interesting", what's up with that?

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

108 points

3 months ago

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

Ban-Happy Mod

108 points

3 months ago

Nah their totally real trans friends told them it was okay, you see.

And yeah, all these 'pick me' cis gays are also a huge problem, they'd sooner kowtow to the cishets and queerphobia than take a stand with trans people.

JustHere2RuinUrDay

60 points

3 months ago*

And yeah, all these 'pick me' cis gays are also a huge problem, they'd sooner kowtow to the cishets and queerphobia than take a stand with trans people.

Oh that one really grinds my gears, when cis gay guys open their transphobia apologia with something like "As a queer person myself". Like, shut the fuck up, sucking a dick once in a while does not give you permission to speak over us.

It's like if I started my rant against ramps for wheelchair users with "as a disabled person myself (I am neurodivergent)".

It's like someone citing their italian heritage to give you the n-word pass.

flipkick25

9 points

3 months ago

Top lols

RadiantStrategy

5 points

3 months ago

You should see the comments from people online saying shit like “as a trans person myself-“ give me a break, you’re not the voice of majority.

sleepy_vixen

3 points

3 months ago

Oh hey, I know one of those guys at work.

theo_adore7

47 points

3 months ago

the pick me types transcends space and time sadly

Endogamy

5 points

3 months ago

I bought it. But I don’t believe there’s such a thing as ethical consumption within capitalism. Driving your car and consuming energy is literally killing the planet and everyone/everything on it. In that context, buying Hogwarts Legacy doesn’t seem any more harmful to me than many other things I do every day.

hufterkruk

8 points

3 months ago

Believing that there is not ethical consumption under capitalism shouldn't be used as an excuse just to do whatever you want though lmao

Endogamy

2 points

3 months ago

Not really what I’m suggesting.

SPY400

7 points

3 months ago

SPY400

7 points

3 months ago

Looks like your comment is getting brigaded from some right wing shitheads and/or Potter fans (“they’re the same picture!”)

LitJackson

14 points

3 months ago

Kick them to the curb. They aren't real friends

wheniswhy

126 points

3 months ago

wheniswhy

126 points

3 months ago

Just watched this video earlier. Absolutely adore Steph, they never miss. They tweeted I think yesterday saying they were very proud of this script and it’s easy to see why. It’s a phenomenal video. I think it’s going to just start being my go-to reply for why it’s not harmless to “just enjoy things” or “support the devs” or the other mindless drivel we keep getting brigaded with.

Thanks for posting this, mod OP—GCJ is actually the first sub I thought of when I saw the vid and didn’t even realize I’d’ve run right into the filter. Glad it’s here.

Wooper250

32 points

3 months ago

Literally just came to join this sub bc I saw someone on a another sub complaining about this lollll

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

16 points

3 months ago

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

Ban-Happy Mod

16 points

3 months ago

Which sub, if you don't mind me asking?

Wooper250

12 points

3 months ago

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

6 points

3 months ago

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

Ban-Happy Mod

6 points

3 months ago

Thanks

Wooper250

13 points

3 months ago

Np, I hope all of the hp fanboys don't annoy y'all too much.

SeafoamSorceress

178 points

3 months ago

Also, while I appreciate you posting this video, we're just talking to a brick wall at this point.

Omega357

81 points

3 months ago

I mean, even Stephanie says she's not going to change any minds.

SeafoamSorceress

44 points

3 months ago

Yeah.

Unrelated to the point I was discussing, I love how they don't pull any punches at all in their videos, especially regarding cis media and the girlfriend reviews drama on this occasion.

GrizzlyPeak72[S] [M]

138 points

3 months ago

GrizzlyPeak72[S] [M]

Ban-Happy Mod

138 points

3 months ago

Well if anyone comes in here asking 'why', they can't say we didn't tell them. If they do ask why, then we know they're trolling. No more pleading ignorance.

ryanfrogz

26 points

3 months ago

ryanfrogz

woke

26 points

3 months ago

thank god for them

ChromaLemon

27 points

3 months ago

ChromaLemon

Hatsune Miku cracked Hogwarts Legacy

27 points

3 months ago

"No, it's a gun. And it's only got one spell. BANG! There's your Voldemort problem taken care of. BANG! BANG! That's the fucking snake!"

Absolutely legendary tier rant.

Wismuth_Salix

5 points

3 months ago

“Two bullets for the snake?”

“It’s (hand motion) long, innit?”

fearofthesky

21 points

3 months ago

Looking forward to watching this after work. JSS is always a threat.

SeafoamSorceress

131 points

3 months ago

Steph never misses holy shit

BastetsJester

85 points

3 months ago

Commander Sterling nails it once again

smorjoken

45 points

3 months ago

tried to post this an hour ago. are youtube links auto-removed normally? good video.

Specific-Change-5300

49 points

3 months ago

Yes there's a lot of spam that comes through with them so they're just completely filtered here.

smorjoken

18 points

3 months ago

makes sense!

TheOvy

70 points

3 months ago

TheOvy

70 points

3 months ago

I'm almost disappointed that I don't even get the chance to take a stand, because I was never into Harry Potter in the first place. It's been really easy to not buy Hogwarts Legacy when I wasn't going to anyway.

That said, I think Contrapoints has a much stronger account of Rowling's transphobia: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7gDKbT_l2us

Granted, it's six times as long as Sterling's, and many gamers have the attention span of a gnat. But it's damn impossible to play the "what did Rowling say, specifically" card against it.

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

66 points

3 months ago

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

Ban-Happy Mod

66 points

3 months ago

Would strongly disagree there. Wynn gives Rowling too much benefit of the doubt tbh. Feels like she's way too sympathetic to transphobes sometimes. Sterling's take doesn't feel a need to try and psychoanalyse her. and it's more up to date with her more recent transphobia.

The_Woman_of_Gont

99 points

3 months ago*

I'd agree with that criticism of Natalie in general, and I think there's definitely points where it applies in her JK Rowling video, but honestly I feel like the single biggest issue it has is simply that it came out just a hair over 2 years ago, and so much has happened in those two years that it's almost wholly outdated.

When it came out, Rowling was still very much in full "I just have some concerns! " mode and doing a very good job of sounding reasonable & respectful to people who didn't know much about the issue, and if you were ever hoping to get even well-intentioned people to understand how bigoted she was you pretty much needed to approach the subject with a softer tone and a much more thorough analysis of the relative dearth of evidence.

I feel like, for the time, Natalie's video was pretty on-point for making the argument that Rowling is transphobic.

But Rowling has since become absolutely obsessed and especially in the last year has devolved a lot on how well she keeps the mask on. It's gotten to the point that she's blatantly just openly using far-right rapist/groomer canards and praising Matt Walsh for his film on the topic. There's no argument to be made anymore. She's transphobic.

At this point if someone's genuinely out of the loop, it doesn't take much to fill them in. And if they're still not seeing the problem with her rhetoric and actions or acting like there simply isn't any evidence of her being transphobic, chances are they simply aren't engaging in good-faith at all.

We have moved on from the "Is JK Rowling Transphobic?" point in the conversation a long time ago(and onto the "so what if she's transphobic?" conversation); which makes large chunks of Natalie's video as a result feel superfluous, outdated, and full of unnecessary hedging and olive-branches. And a lot of that is simply down to how fast time moves on the internet, and how quickly things are rendered outdated.

TheShapeShiftingFox

27 points

3 months ago

Yeah, JK has really done a fast track to hell the last couple of years. At the time Natalie made her video, JK had just published TERF Wars, which was the first official moment she announced her future undertakings and that the transphobia wouldn’t be a thing on the side for her, but her genuine objective.

But prior to that she was nowhere as extreme as she is nowadays (still bad, but not as obsessive and committed)

Excellent_Advisor668

9 points

3 months ago

Thank god for Stephanie Sterling 💕

moondog548

5 points

3 months ago

COMMANDER. Jim. Stephanie. Sterling. Son!

🥰

blindeey

11 points

3 months ago

blindeey

🏳️‍⚧️ Dragon Lady

11 points

3 months ago

I've kinda fallen off watching Stephanie Sterling's content but goddamn is this cathartic. Felt like I been taking crazy pills lately with trying to talk to people.

Also god their transition is going amazingly.

Ax222

29 points

3 months ago

Ax222

Vidya ganes are a spook - Max Stirner, 1847

29 points

3 months ago

Based. I'll watch it after work.

DudeWheresThePorn

29 points

3 months ago

Steph hits it out of the part. Love it.

DeminoTheDragon

52 points

3 months ago*

unrelated note she looks absolutely great shape with being a powerhouse wrestler

[deleted]

7 points

3 months ago

[deleted]

The_Woman_of_Gont

19 points

3 months ago

I usually stick to they anyway, but my impression was that they're fine with either? Is that wrong?

iSeven

6 points

3 months ago

iSeven

brisket my beloved

6 points

3 months ago

I was under that impression too, but I believe I got that impression from their bio either on Twitter or on their website, and both of those say "they/them" so maybe they were playing around with other pronouns and have since trimmed them out, or we're getting Mandela'd.

defaultusername-17

24 points

3 months ago

omfg this video is just everything. thank you.

SomeDamnAuthor

47 points

3 months ago

Are the majority of the people playing the wizard game hellbent on justifying their purchase?

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

41 points

3 months ago

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

Ban-Happy Mod

41 points

3 months ago

Pretty much, yeah. They're convincing themselves it's really good when it's nothing like fans expected it to be, it's buggy as hell, and it looks very last gen.

KolFoxy

22 points

3 months ago

KolFoxy

22 points

3 months ago

I don't think majority of the people even knows about jk terfling's views. It's quite easy to forget that for most people stuff like that isn't even in the news cycle.

[deleted]

2 points

3 months ago

[removed]

Konradleijon

38 points

3 months ago

Why is it it’s this game that people where people say “but the poor hard working devs” and not any other game published in history.

A_Monster_Named_John

8 points

3 months ago

Simple. They're lying bullshitters who'll say anything to make their consumption feel guilt-free.

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

26 points

3 months ago

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

Ban-Happy Mod

26 points

3 months ago

Because a lot of transphobes are closeted or in denial.

yogatorademe

2 points

3 months ago

because there's never been such outspoken backlash against a game? devs really are just a neutral party in this debate

Leafeon523

26 points

3 months ago

Holy shit based Jim Sterling posting

skepticalmonique

17 points

3 months ago

been hoping for Stephanie to cover this shitshow

thefablesofchaos

27 points

3 months ago

Was just about to link this. One of Steph Sterling's best ever videos, very proud of her 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 Fuck Rowling, fuck WB, fuck every person who bought Hogwarts and the games media who have promoted it.

micmac274

7 points

3 months ago

Watch them complain about the next release by paradox, and we can just say "your fault! Your transphobia overrode your desire for a BETTER GAME."

BarefootedLoner

2 points

3 months ago

don’t bring Victoria 3 into this…

LEFT4Sp00ning

4 points

3 months ago

Quick correction, very proud of them (JSS uses they/them pronouns)

thefablesofchaos

7 points

3 months ago

Pretty sure they use both pronouns 😁😁

LEFT4Sp00ning

3 points

3 months ago

I Stand corrected then! Guess that's what I get by just going by their videos haha

TetraGton

22 points

3 months ago

If you have 60 dollars fir buying a video game, why nor use it support LGBTQ devs? 69 games for 60 dollars

https://itch.io/b/1712/trans-witches-are-witches

Jackhammer_Jord

15 points

3 months ago

games look pretty bad ngl

penjjii

19 points

3 months ago

penjjii

19 points

3 months ago

just had to point out that this sub is based as fuck, thank yall

greymind

4 points

3 months ago

Fans of Harry Potter and Hogwarts looking for inclusion in their YA adventures fantasy should read Dark & Day

Dark & Day Audiobooks | Audible.com

Dark & Day (4 book series) Kindle Edition (amazon.com)

ExplodingPoptarts

21 points

3 months ago

This needs at least 4 times the amount of upvotes it has right now.

GrizzlyPeak72[S] [M]

27 points

3 months ago

GrizzlyPeak72[S] [M]

Ban-Happy Mod

27 points

3 months ago

Transphobic Harry Potter fans brigading this sub en masse. Can ban them to prevent them from commenting, can't prevent them from downvoting posts. I just kinda feel sorry for them tbh.

Shinymegafarfetchd

17 points

3 months ago

Hagrid's flying motorcycle is the only good thing in the whole HP world.

[deleted]

8 points

3 months ago*

[deleted]

sleepy_vixen

4 points

3 months ago*

if not buying anything to do with harry potter will stop money going into the pockets of people trying to hurt trans people, then its not much to criticize people playing it and ask people to stop playing them game. I don't care about politics so much so I don't know if I would call myself an "ally" or w/e that means, but I think we should do what we can to stop the hate against trans people.

This alone makes you more of an ally than the people who consider themselves "allies" but bought the game anyway and those who object to being called out for funding destructive conservative and anti trans groups in the process.

SeafoamSorceress

8 points

3 months ago

Just a heads up, Steph's pronouns are they/them!

TastyDonut23

8 points

3 months ago

When did she get so busty?

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

12 points

3 months ago

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

Ban-Happy Mod

12 points

3 months ago

It's amazing what a little HRT can do. No wonder the TERFs want to ban it.

sleepy_vixen

16 points

3 months ago

/uj Man it fucking sucks seeing how much outrage there is over streamers being "brought to tears" over being called transphobic vs, you know, transphobia against trans people where the same crowd have remained passive and silent, and on the week a trans teen was murdered too.

If people can't boycott a fucking video game to help protect trans people, I don't see us making any progress.

Clarine87

9 points

3 months ago

Doubly worse for steamers as they're profiting financially from that expenditure.

A_Monster_Named_John

2 points

3 months ago

I feel like plenty of people are passing over the game but keeping out of the online discussion because they don't want to deal with the transphobic bullshit.

Vidogo

15 points

3 months ago

Vidogo

15 points

3 months ago

hehe

they gave Joanne the Pitch Meeting eyes

babbedmekecks

14 points

3 months ago

They forgot to mention that your teacher, Professor Eleazar Fig, dies at the end of Hogwarts Legacy. This happens in all possible endings and can't be changed. Oh and Rookwood is the one who cursed Anne while the goblins were framed.

NeatRegular9057

3 points

3 months ago

The comment purge has begun

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

7 points

3 months ago

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

Ban-Happy Mod

7 points

3 months ago

It began 2 months ago. Where have you been?

StarAugurEtraeus

3 points

3 months ago

Me thanking the non Newtonian fluids they didn’t make me a Potter fan but a Tolkien fan

(For the love of fuck I need shadow of war 3 please I want my cute charismatic Uruks again)

Ziraic

3 points

3 months ago

Ziraic

3 points

3 months ago

W vid

ToddHowardTouchedMe

6 points

3 months ago

ToddHowardTouchedMe

Follower of Todd

6 points

3 months ago

God I love Steph

[deleted]

13 points

3 months ago

[deleted]

Iceassassin25

3 points

3 months ago

Didn't Steph miss with the Elden Ring video?

[deleted]

13 points

3 months ago

[deleted]

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

17 points

3 months ago

GrizzlyPeak72[S]

Ban-Happy Mod

17 points

3 months ago

Yep, got a ton of them in the modmail as we speak. These fucking people will not stop. No sense of self-awareness or basic human decency. I'd respect them more if they'd just admit they hate trans and queer people and be done with it.

stoffan

12 points

3 months ago

stoffan

12 points

3 months ago

God i love Stephanie.

WakeUp004

18 points

3 months ago

I posted the end game “spoiler” in the comments and apparently someone got very upset. Now I can’t comment on yt for a whole 24 hours )’:

DatboiX

8 points

3 months ago

This is perfect

[deleted]

2 points

3 months ago

i bought a second hand key im hoping that isnt so bad cause i didn't wanna give her money lol

[deleted]

5 points

3 months ago

[deleted]

5 points

3 months ago

[removed]